FAQ Valuation Process Documentation

Interested in Valuing your Business? Contact a Certified Appraiser in Australia

Business Valuation FAQs

Find answers to common questions about company valuations, methodologies, and financial analysis

Search through our valuation knowledge base

What information does a valuator need from me?

A valuator needs from you three to five years of complete financial statements including income statements, balance sheets, and cash flow statements, federal and state tax returns, detailed schedules of assets and liabilities, accounts receivable and payable aging reports, inventory listings, customer and supplier information, organizational documents, shareholder agreements, and strategic planning materials. Financial documentation forms the foundation of the valuation, requiring historical profit and loss statements showing revenue trends, expense patterns, and profitability metrics. Balance sheets provide asset and liability details including fixed assets, inventory levels, receivables, and debt obligations. Tax returns verify reported income and provide insights into tax strategies affecting financial presentation. Detailed schedules break down revenue by customer or product line, identify concentration risks, and show contract terms. Asset schedules list equipment, real estate, vehicles, and other tangible assets with acquisition dates and depreciation. Customer lists reveal concentration risks and retention patterns. Organizational documents including articles of incorporation, bylaws, operating agreements, and shareholder agreements clarify ownership structure and rights. Buy-sell agreements specify valuation methodologies or restrictions affecting value. Employee information shows headcount, key personnel, compensation structures, and organizational depth. Strategic plans, budgets, and forecasts provide forward-looking perspectives. Industry reports and competitive analysis materials help appraisers understand market positioning. The more complete and organized your documentation, the more accurate your valuation and faster the process proceeds.

What are red flags in business valuations?

Red flags in business valuations include significant revenue or customer concentration where a few customers represent over 30 percent of sales, declining revenue or profitability trends without clear explanation, heavy dependence on owner or key personnel whose departure would devastate operations, inconsistent or incomplete financial records suggesting poor controls or potential manipulation, significant related party transactions at non-market terms, pending litigation or regulatory issues creating uncertainty, and divergence between tax returns and financial statements without reasonable explanation. Customer concentration creates vulnerability if major customers leave, justifying valuation discounts or raising questions about sustainability. Revenue declines or margin compression signal competitive pressures, market challenges, or operational problems requiring investigation. Owner dependency where the business cannot operate without specific individuals creates key person risk reducing transferability and value. Poor financial record quality including missing documentation, unexplained variances, or lack of supporting schedules undermines confidence in reported results. Related party transactions like below-market rents or non-arm's length supplier relationships require normalization but also raise questions about true economics. Pending lawsuits, regulatory investigations, or compliance issues create contingent liabilities and uncertainty affecting value. Material differences between tax returns and financial statements beyond normal book-tax differences suggest aggressive accounting or potential manipulation. High employee turnover, customer complaints, or operational disruptions indicate underlying problems. Unusual transactions near valuation dates potentially designed to inflate value deserve scrutiny.

What is a quality of earnings analysis?

A quality of earnings analysis is a detailed examination of a company's financial results to determine the sustainability, accuracy, and reliability of reported earnings by identifying one-time items, aggressive accounting policies, non-recurring revenue or expenses, and potential manipulation that could distort true earning power. This analysis goes beyond accepting reported GAAP earnings to understand the quality and sustainability of profits, distinguishing between recurring operational earnings and one-time gains, accounting adjustments, or unsustainable revenue. Quality of earnings analysis examines revenue recognition policies to ensure revenue is properly earned and collectible, not prematurely recognized or artificially inflated. It reviews expense classifications identifying costs improperly capitalized or deferred that should flow through current earnings. The analysis identifies non-recurring items like lawsuit settlements, asset sales, or restructuring charges that inflate or depress current earnings but will not continue. It assesses working capital trends revealing whether earnings convert to cash or remain tied up in receivables and inventory. Quality of earnings analysis evaluates customer and supplier concentration, contract terms, pricing power, and competitive positioning affecting earnings sustainability. It reviews accounting policy changes, estimates, and judgments that could materially impact reported results. This analysis is critical in valuations because sustainable normalized earnings drive value, while one-time items or accounting manipulations create misleading impressions requiring adjustment.

How do financial statements impact valuation?

Financial statements impact valuation by providing the fundamental data for calculating earnings, cash flows, assets, and liabilities that drive value conclusions through income, market, and asset-based approaches, with statement quality, trends, and normalization adjustments significantly affecting final values. Income statements showing revenue growth, profitability margins, and expense patterns determine normalized earnings that get capitalized or serve as basis for applying market multiples. Strong revenue growth, improving margins, and operating leverage justify premium valuations, while declining sales or compressed margins raise concerns reducing value. Balance sheets reveal asset quality, working capital requirements, debt levels, and tangible net worth affecting both asset-based values and enterprise value calculations. Cash flow statements show whether earnings convert to cash or remain trapped in working capital, with strong cash conversion supporting higher values. Financial statement quality matters enormously; clean, audited statements with clear documentation command more confidence than unaudited statements with inconsistencies or gaps. Trends over three to five years reveal whether the business is strengthening or weakening, growing or declining, improving efficiency or losing competitive position. Normalizing adjustments to remove owner perks, one-time items, and non-operating expenses can increase EBITDA by 20 to 40 percent, dramatically impacting value. Financial statement analysis also identifies risks like customer concentration, working capital strain, or deteriorating receivables quality that justify valuation discounts.

What is due diligence in the valuation process?

Due diligence in the valuation process is the comprehensive investigation and verification of information provided by the company to ensure accuracy, completeness, and reliability of data underlying valuation conclusions, including financial analysis, operational assessment, legal review, and market research. Financial due diligence verifies reported revenue and expenses through source documentation like invoices, contracts, and bank statements, ensuring financial statements accurately represent business performance. It analyzes revenue quality assessing customer concentration, contract terms, recurring versus one-time revenue, and collectibility of receivables. Operational due diligence examines facilities, equipment condition, production processes, technology systems, and organizational capabilities supporting reported results and future projections. Legal due diligence reviews corporate structure, ownership documentation, material contracts, litigation history, regulatory compliance, intellectual property protection, and environmental issues affecting value or creating contingent liabilities. Customer due diligence validates major customer relationships, contract terms, retention rates, and satisfaction levels. Supplier due diligence assesses key vendor relationships, pricing terms, and supply chain risks. Market due diligence researches industry conditions, competitive landscape, market positioning, and growth prospects. The valuator conducts management interviews probing business strategy, competitive advantages, challenges, and future plans. Due diligence identifies red flags requiring further investigation or valuation adjustments and builds confidence in the reliability of information supporting value conclusions.

How do I dispute a business valuation?

You dispute a business valuation by engaging your own qualified appraiser to perform an independent valuation, identifying specific methodological errors, questionable assumptions, or factual inaccuracies in the original appraisal, documenting your objections with supporting evidence, and potentially pursuing resolution through negotiation, mediation, arbitration, or litigation depending on the context. Start by having a credentialed appraiser review the disputed valuation identifying technical errors like inappropriate methodology selection, incorrect discount rate calculations, improper comparable company selection, or failure to apply appropriate discounts or premiums. Challenge factual errors including incorrect financial data, mischaracterization of business operations, overlooking key assets or contracts, or failing to consider relevant market information. Question assumptions that seem unreasonable including overly pessimistic growth projections, excessive risk premiums, or inappropriate normalization adjustments. In tax disputes, prepare a rebuttal report from your qualified appraiser explaining why the IRS valuation is incorrect and presenting alternative supportable value. In divorce or shareholder disputes, your appraiser's testimony can counter opposing expert opinions. Document all objections clearly with supporting evidence including comparable transaction data, industry research, or financial analysis. Consider whether the disputed valuation violates professional standards like USPAP or AICPA guidelines, potentially undermining its credibility. Assess whether negotiation or mediation might resolve differences more efficiently than litigation. If litigation is necessary, ensure your appraiser has strong credentials and testimony experience to withstand cross-examination.

What makes a valuation defensible in court?

A valuation is defensible in court when it is performed by a qualified credentialed appraiser with relevant experience, uses appropriate methodologies properly applied, relies on supportable assumptions and reliable data, complies with professional standards like USPAP, contains comprehensive documentation explaining all conclusions, and withstands scrutiny under cross-examination from opposing experts. The appraiser's credentials including ABV, ASA, or CVA combined with relevant experience establish credibility as a qualified expert. Methodology selection must be appropriate for the business type, purpose, and available data, with clear explanation of why chosen methods are most relevant. Assumptions including discount rates, growth rates, and comparable company selections must be reasonable and supportable through market data, industry research, or empirical studies. All data sources must be reliable and verifiable, with financial information reconciled to tax returns and supporting documentation. The valuation report must comprehensively document the analysis including detailed financial analysis, market research, comparable transaction data, discount and premium support, and clear explanation of how conclusions were reached. Professional standards compliance including USPAP requirements for scope of work, assumptions and limiting conditions, and certification provides framework for defensible work. The appraiser must be able to testify credibly, explaining complex concepts clearly, defending methodology choices, and maintaining composure under cross-examination. Prior court acceptance of the appraiser's testimony strengthens credibility. Independence from parties and absence of conflicts of interest are essential for court acceptance.

How do economic conditions affect business valuations?

Economic conditions affect business valuations by influencing discount rates, growth expectations, market multiples, buyer demand, and risk perceptions that collectively impact what investors will pay for businesses, with strong economies supporting higher valuations and recessions or uncertainty depressing values across most industries. Interest rates directly affect discount rates used in DCF analysis; when risk-free rates rise from 3 percent to 5 percent, discount rates increase proportionally, reducing present values of future cash flows by 15 to 25 percent or more. Economic growth expectations influence revenue projections and terminal value assumptions, with robust economies justifying optimistic growth while recessions require conservative projections. Market multiples from comparable companies and transactions fluctuate with economic cycles; during strong markets, EBITDA multiples might reach 7x to 10x, while recessions compress multiples to 3x to 5x for the same industries. Buyer demand and capital availability affect transaction values; abundant capital and competitive bidding during strong economies drive premium prices, while capital scarcity and risk aversion during downturns depress values. Industry-specific impacts vary; some businesses like discount retailers or bankruptcy services may strengthen during recessions while luxury goods or discretionary spending businesses suffer. Credit conditions affect leveraged transactions; tight credit markets reduce buyer financing capacity, limiting prices they can pay. Inflation impacts both revenue growth and cost structures, requiring careful analysis of real versus nominal growth. Economic uncertainty increases risk premiums added to discount rates, reducing valuations even for stable businesses.

What is the role of industry trends in valuations?

The role of industry trends in valuations is to provide context for assessing a company's competitive position, growth prospects, risk profile, and appropriate valuation multiples by analyzing whether the industry is growing or declining, consolidating or fragmenting, facing disruption or stability, and commanding premium or discount valuations relative to broader markets. Growing industries with favorable demographics, technological tailwinds, or regulatory support justify optimistic growth projections and premium multiples, while declining industries facing obsolescence, substitution, or regulatory headwinds require conservative assumptions and discounted values. Industry consolidation trends affect valuations; fragmented industries ripe for roll-ups may attract strategic buyers paying premiums, while mature consolidated industries offer fewer synergy opportunities. Technology disruption threatens traditional business models; industries facing digital transformation like retail, media, or transportation require careful assessment of competitive sustainability. Regulatory trends including new compliance requirements, tax changes, or policy shifts materially impact profitability and risk. Competitive dynamics including barriers to entry, pricing power, and customer switching costs determine sustainable margins and growth. Industry multiples from public companies and transactions provide benchmarks; high-growth technology industries might trade at 10x to 15x EBITDA while mature manufacturing industries trade at 4x to 6x. Cyclicality affects valuation timing; valuing cyclical businesses at peak earnings produces inflated values while trough valuations appear artificially low. Industry trends inform discount rate selection, with stable industries warranting lower rates and volatile industries requiring higher risk premiums.

How do I update an existing valuation?

You update an existing valuation by engaging the original appraiser or a new qualified professional to perform a limited scope update analyzing what has changed since the original valuation date, including financial performance, market conditions, company developments, and industry dynamics, then adjusting the prior value conclusion or performing a new full valuation if changes are material. Minor updates for businesses with stable operations and unchanged market conditions may simply roll forward the prior valuation using updated financial results and current market multiples, requiring less time and cost than full revaluations. The appraiser reviews financial performance since the prior valuation, comparing actual results to projections and assessing whether trends have strengthened or weakened. Market condition changes including interest rate movements, economic shifts, or industry multiple changes require adjusting discount rates or valuation multiples. Company-specific developments like new contracts, lost customers, acquisitions, divestitures, or management changes materially affect value. Significant changes warrant full revaluations rather than updates; if revenue changed by more than 20 percent, major customers were lost, or business model shifted substantially, limited updates are insufficient. For ESOP companies requiring annual valuations, appraisers typically perform full valuations annually rather than updates to comply with Department of Labor requirements. Tax and legal matters often require fresh valuations rather than updates if the original valuation is more than 12 months old. Updates are most appropriate for monitoring value trends, internal planning, or situations where recent full valuations exist and changes have been modest.

What are the stages of a business valuation?

The stages of a business valuation include initial consultation and engagement, data collection and document review, research and industry analysis, financial statement analysis and normalization, valuation methodology selection and application, reconciliation of value indications, report preparation and quality review, and final delivery with explanation and discussion. Initial consultation clarifies the valuation purpose, standard of value, ownership interest being valued, and special considerations affecting scope. Engagement letters formalize terms, fees, timeline, and responsibilities. Data collection gathers financial statements, tax returns, asset schedules, customer information, contracts, and operational data. Document review verifies completeness and identifies additional information needs. Research phase analyzes industry conditions, competitive landscape, economic factors, and comparable company or transaction data. Financial analysis normalizes historical statements removing one-time items, owner perks, and non-operating elements to determine sustainable earning power. Methodology selection chooses appropriate income, market, or asset-based approaches based on business characteristics and data availability. Valuation execution applies selected methodologies including DCF analysis, market multiple application, or asset valuations. Reconciliation weighs different value indications considering their reliability and appropriateness, reaching a final value conclusion. Report drafting documents all analysis, assumptions, methodologies, and conclusions in format meeting professional standards. Quality review by senior appraisers checks calculations, assumptions, and conclusions. Final delivery presents findings to clients with explanation and opportunity for questions.

How long does data collection take for a valuation?

Data collection for a valuation typically takes one to two weeks for organized businesses with readily available documentation, though it can extend to three to four weeks or longer for companies with incomplete records, complex structures, or multiple locations requiring extensive information gathering. The timeline depends heavily on client preparedness; businesses with organized financial records, documented processes, and designated contacts can provide information quickly, while companies lacking systems or experiencing turnover face delays. Standard document requests including three to five years of financial statements, tax returns, and supporting schedules can often be compiled within days if records are well-maintained. Detailed operational information like customer lists, supplier contracts, employee data, and asset inventories may require additional time to compile from various sources. Complex businesses with multiple entities, international operations, or diverse business lines need longer collection periods to gather comprehensive information from all locations and divisions. Follow-up requests for clarification, additional details, or missing documentation extend timelines, particularly if original submissions raise questions or reveal gaps. Management interviews and facility tours add days to the collection phase but provide valuable insights beyond documentation. Your responsiveness dramatically impacts timelines; prompt replies to information requests keep valuations on schedule while delays waiting for documents can extend projects by weeks. Organizing information before engaging the appraiser accelerates collection; creating organized files with financial statements, tax returns, contracts, and operational data ready for delivery streamlines the process.

What historical financial records are needed?

Historical financial records needed for business valuations include three to five years of complete financial statements with income statements, balance sheets, and cash flow statements, preferably compiled, reviewed, or audited by CPAs, along with corresponding federal and state tax returns, detailed general ledgers, and supporting schedules breaking down revenue, expenses, assets, and liabilities. Income statements should show monthly or quarterly detail revealing revenue trends, seasonality, expense patterns, and profitability progression. Balance sheets need supporting schedules for major accounts including detailed fixed asset registers with acquisition dates and depreciation, accounts receivable aging reports, inventory listings by category or product, and debt schedules showing terms and payment obligations. Revenue schedules breaking down sales by customer, product line, or service type identify concentration risks and growth drivers. Expense detail separating operating costs from owner discretionary expenses, related party transactions, and one-time items facilitates normalization. Tax returns verify reported income and reveal tax strategies affecting financial presentation, with reconciliations explaining book-tax differences. Cash flow statements or bank statements demonstrate actual cash generation and working capital patterns. For businesses with significant changes like acquisitions, divestitures, or restructurings, financial information both before and after changes helps appraisers understand impacts. Interim financial statements for the current year bring valuations current beyond the most recent year-end. The more complete and organized your historical records, the more accurate your valuation and the less time appraisers spend requesting additional information.

Do I need tax returns for a business valuation?

You need tax returns for a business valuation in virtually all situations because they provide IRS-filed documentation verifying reported income, revealing tax strategies affecting financial presentation, and offering credibility that unaudited financial statements alone cannot provide, with most qualified appraisers requiring three to five years of complete federal and state returns. Tax returns serve as independent verification of financial results because they are filed with authorities and subject to penalties for misstatement, making them more reliable than internally prepared financial statements. They reveal the company's actual tax position including effective tax rates, tax credits, loss carryforwards, and strategies affecting cash taxes. Reconciling tax returns to financial statements identifies book-tax differences requiring explanation, with material unexplained variances raising red flags about financial statement reliability. Tax returns show S corporation distributions, partnership allocations, or C corporation dividends affecting owner benefits and normalization adjustments. They reveal related party transactions, officer compensation, depreciation methods, and accounting policies that impact reported earnings. For IRS-related valuations including estate tax, gift tax, or charitable contributions, tax returns are absolutely essential because the IRS will scrutinize consistency between reported income and valuations. Litigation contexts often require tax returns because opposing counsel will demand them and courts expect valuations based on filed returns. The only situations where tax returns might not be needed are preliminary indicative valuations for internal planning, though even these benefit from tax return analysis.

What is the typical timeline for a business valuation?

The typical timeline for a business valuation is two to six weeks from initial engagement to final report delivery for standard engagements, with simple small business valuations potentially completing in two to three weeks and complex large company or litigation valuations requiring eight to twelve weeks or longer. The timeline breaks into distinct phases: initial consultation and engagement (one to three days), data collection and document review (one to three weeks depending on client responsiveness), research and industry analysis (three to five days), financial analysis and normalization (three to five days), valuation methodology application (five to seven days), report drafting and quality review (five to seven days), and final delivery and discussion (one to two days). Client responsiveness significantly impacts timelines; businesses providing complete organized documentation promptly enable faster completion, while delays gathering information extend projects. Valuation complexity affects duration; straightforward service businesses with clean financials complete faster than manufacturing companies with significant equipment, real estate, and inventory requiring detailed asset analysis. Purpose influences timeline; preliminary valuations for internal planning may be expedited while litigation valuations requiring extensive documentation and defensibility take longer. Appraiser workload and scheduling affect start dates and completion; busy seasons may mean waiting for appraiser availability. Rush requests can sometimes be accommodated for additional fees but require client commitment to immediate document provision. Planning ahead by engaging appraisers early and preparing documentation before needed deadlines ensures adequate time for quality work.

No questions found matching your search. Try different keywords.