What is ESOP Valuation and Why Is It Important for Your Business?

ESOP stands for Employee Stock Ownership Plan, which is a retirement plan that allows employees to become owners of the company they work for. ESOPs have become an increasingly popular way for business owners to transition ownership to their employees, while also providing tax benefits for both the company and the employees.

ESOP valuation is the process of determining the value of a business for the purpose of establishing an ESOP. Accurate ESOP valuation is critical in ensuring that the business owner and employees receive a fair and reasonable price for the company’s stock.

Valuing a private company’s stock is critical to the operation of an employee stock ownership plan (ESOP), as the value of employees’ retirement benefits relies on the per-share price of the plan sponsor’s common stock allocated to their individual ESOP accounts. The valuation of ESOPs is also the central focus of investigations and lawsuits brought by participants and the Department of Labor (DOL), who often claim that the ESOP paid too much when purchasing the stock in the sponsoring employer.

ESOP Valuation Requirements & Process

ESOP valuation is a complex process that requires careful analysis and expertise in business valuation. To establish an ESOP, the Internal Revenue Code (IRC) requires that the ESOP purchase the stock of the company from the owner(s) at fair market value, as defined by IRC section 401(a)(28)(C).

The Department of Labor (DOL) is the regulatory body that oversees ESOPs and as part of the ESOP valuation process, the DOL requires that the valuation be conducted by an independent and qualified appraiser who has no financial interest in the company. The appraiser must also use generally accepted valuation methods and principles, and must document their analysis and conclusions in a detailed valuation report.

Under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), the ESOP trustee must determine the “fair market value” of qualifying employer securities, which cannot be more than the amount paid in good faith. When selling stock, the ESOP must also not sell it for less than its “fair market value.” The ESOP’s trustee is responsible for making a fiduciary decision on whether the value negotiated or assigned is not more than the “fair market value.”

InteleK are experts in complex, high stakes valuations such as ESOPs that must withstand outside scrutiny. Such valuations must be state-of-the-art, from both a sophisticated legal and financial perspective that is based on robust, well established methodologies, customized for each case and consider a full range of relative alternatives with complete citations and support within the report, producing highly defensible conclusions of value. What is also paramount is the application of the highest ethical and moral judgement required for such a valuation.  

Customized ESOP Valuation Services: Tailored Solutions for Your Unique Business Needs

ESOPs have tremendous benefits and proven to be successful for thousands of companies and millions of employees. The National Center for Employee Ownership (NCEO), as of 2021, notes there are approximately 6,600 employee stock ownership plans (ESOPs) in the United States, employing approximately 14 million people. Although ESOPs are not the right fit for various different scenarios, education is key for business owners to identify the possibilities at their fingertips.

Once in the valuation stage of the ESOP process, InteleK’s customized ESOP valuation services provide tailored solutions to meet the unique business needs of companies seeking to establish or maintain an ESOP. In addition to business valuations for the initial transactions, InteleK can provide guidance regarding the benefits of various debt structures, the impact of various business improvements on valuation and the value of complex financial instruments such as options that can be issued to owners as of part an ESOP transaction.   InteleK also provides annual valuations that are required to ensure the ESOP remains in compliance with regulations and to support the company’s ongoing obligations to provide fairness opinions to plan. Additionally, the valuation process can help determine the fair market value of debt, which can have significant implications for ESOP structure and financing.

As ESOPs continue to gain popularity as a way for companies to attract, retain, and reward employees, it’s important to work with experienced valuation professionals who understand the complexities of these transactions and can help ensure that the company is meeting its fiduciary responsibilities and creating long-term value for all stakeholders.”

our team

Meet InteleK’s Leaders

Andrew Mackson, CFA, ABV
co-founder & Partner
Cameron Braid,
Co-Founder & Partner